| Platinum | The Vermillion |
| Gold | Adolios |
| Silver | The Oyster Bar |
| Bronze | Muelle 37 |
| Top Pick | Cocteleria El Marisquero |
| Top Pick | De LA Rosa Seafood Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Dirty Al's Seafood Market & Cajun Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Escondido Grill |
| Top Pick | Mariscos de la Rosa |
| Top Pick | The Surfing Crab |