| Platinum | Cookielicious by Mk |
| Gold | Pan De Cada Dia |
| Silver | What's Baking? LLC |
| Bronze | Monique's Cake Co |
| Top Pick | Christy's Cake Shop |
| Top Pick | Dolci Delizie |
| Top Pick | Great American Cookies |
| Top Pick | Linda's Cakes & Desserts Specialty Shop |
| Top Pick | Nestle Toll House Cafe |
| Top Pick | Sugar Bee Sweets Bakery |